Best dog training collar

Best Dog Training Collar For The Most Difficult Dogs


This article is intended for those who are dealing with a particularly difficult dog. While there are many stubborn dogs in the world, there are some that can try the patience of even the calmest trainer. So, how do you solve this dilemma? Chances are, you care about your dog, and you don’t want to get rid of them. However, your dog is probably causing some serious distress or else you would not be reading this article.

When more extreme measures are called for, a few pieces of training equipment can go a long way. One of the best things you can do is invest in a training collar of one sort or another. There are many different types of training collars, but most of them fall into one of several categories. We have tried to represent a large variety of training collars in this article so that you can have plenty of options depending on the type of problem you are dealing with and its level of severity.

If you’re in a hurry and just want to know what the best dog training collar is, we recommend the GPS collar.

Garmin T5 GPS Dog Collar
Garmin - Wireless Phone Accessory

Today, we are going to review the following training collars:

  1. Starmark Training Collar
  2. Muxin Collar And Muzzle Combo
  3. COVONO Invisible Fence for Dogs
  4. Country Brook Martingale Heavy Duty Nylon Dog Collar
  5. Garmin T5 GPS Dog Collar

Advantages of Using a Training Collar

Superior Control

Dog standing in the grass in a cool training collar

Despite the huge variety of training collars on the market, they all serve the same primary purpose: to give the trainer a greater degree of control over the dog. Obviously, none of these devices is necessary for the average dog, but a problem dog requires a firm and steady hand.

For instance, a dog that continues to chase other dogs can be discouraged in many ways. You could pull them back with the leash, make them sit, and scold them for their disobedience. However, it would be a lot easier if you had a pinch collar to create a slight deterrent.

Many of the collars here can be combined with other devices for even greater control. As an example, let’s consider dogs with very thick necks. These breeds of dog find it much easier to slip a collar, and this can become a big problem. Bulldog breeds, with their excessively thick necks, are the number one culprits for this kind of problem. You can remedy this issue by connecting any of these collars to a harness. There are many ways, but the easiest is probably to buy an inexpensive D-ring and clamp the collar to the harness.

Plenty Of Versatility

As you will see, the collar is a very basic concept that has been improved upon in many ways. This list is not even a complete list of the many types of specialized collars, but merely a list of the best. For almost any common behavior problem, there is probably a collar that is meant to deal with the problem.

Instant Correction

In the case of pinch collars and choke collars, they provide a disciplinary tool that can be very useful in discouraging unwanted behaviors. These collars are not meant to cause pain, but merely to cause mild discomfort. In most cases, this mild discomfort is enough to make the dog think twice about repeating the behavior.

If a dog pulls against one of these leashes or otherwise begins to get out of control, the negative consequence will happen instantly with no effort to you. The dogs’ momentum does the work. This is also true in the case of the best dog shock collars that work in conjunction with buried cables. The Martingale collar is a good example of a collar that provides only light correction.

Monitoring Possibilities

Since your dog will be wearing their collar 24 hours a day, you can use it as a way to keep tabs on them. There are many devices on the market that combine a collar with some sort of tracking device. These might include GPS trackers, miniature microphones, or miniature cameras. If your dog keeps wandering off and getting into trouble, these types of training collars might be just the thing.

What To Look For In A Training Collar

Although this is a very diverse group of products, there are certain things that you should always check before laying your money down. Here are the most important factors:

Relevance To Your Problem

Most dog owners buy training collars to remedy a specific problem. The first thing you need to consider is what result you hope to achieve. Here is a quick guide to some common dog problems and the collars that might be helpful in combating them:

  • Leash Pulling: Pinch collars, choke collars, Martingale collar
  • Aggression: Muzzle-collar, choke collar,
  • Chewing: Corrective shock collar, camera collar
  • Running Away: GPS collar, camera collar, buried cable shock collar
  • Escaping From Collars: Switch to a harness

Durable Construction

Durability is one of your biggest concerns when buying a product of this type. Most of these specialized training collars are required to take the worst abuse that a dog can dish out. Most of them will need to withstand full resistance, so don’t accept any product that looks like it might be weak.

The band of the collar should be thick, and should not include any plastic snaps. These are fine for small dogs, but those little plastic clips won’t hold up against a medium to large dog when they are resisting at their hardest. Buckles and connectors should be made of steel. Coated steel is the best since it is protected from the elements to a greater degree.

Resistance Against Water

In some cases, these specialized collars will have some sort of electronic device attached to them. When this is the case, it is vitally important to make sure that the product is guaranteed to be 100% waterproof. Water-resistant isn’t good enough in most instances.


As with anything that your dog will wear, you should carefully consider their comfort. If your dog is uncomfortable in one of these collars, they cannot directly tell you so. It is up to you to figure out whether or not the item will be comfortable enough for your dog. Of course, some of these collars are designed to cause discomfort, but only when the dog crosses a certain line.

Under normal circumstances, you don’t want your dog to be irritated with their collar. The more irritated your dog becomes, the harder they will try to remove the collar. If a dog makes a dedicated effort to relieve themselves of an uncomfortable collar, they will very often succeed. Although you should always select durable collars and harnesses, you should also try not to provide too much motivation to escape.

Along these same lines, you should always consider whether or not a particular training device is acceptably humane. For instance, we have not included choke collars because many dog owners find them to be inhumane, and there is some basis for that argument. We have also omitted all bark collars from this list because most of them use an automatic mechanism that shocks the dog every time they bark. Imagine if one of those collars malfunctions and continues to shock the dog until you get home? The risk of traumatizing your pet just isn’t worth the potential gain.

Proven Track Record

You should always avoid “gimmicky” collars that use new and untested technology. While there is nothing wrong with innovation, this is a case where you need reliability above all. As such, you should play it safe and stick to the time-proven designs that have served dog owners well for many years.

Training Collar Reviews:

StarMark Training Collar, Large, Black
1,238 Reviews
StarMark Training Collar, Large, Black
  • Quality and performance driven products for...
  • Tested for safety and health
  • Provide a better quality of living for your...
  • Helps train your dog gently and effectively

This is a good example of a “pinch collar.” If you have never used one of these collars before, its appearance may startle you. At first glance, it looks like some kind of medieval torture device. However, if you look closely, you will see that the spikes inside the collar are quite soft and are unlikely to cause discomfort until the dog pulls.

This type of collar is designed for a dog that doesn’t want to be leash-trained. We consider these devices to be humane because they cause only mild discomfort. Also, the dog has control of the discomfort, as they only need to stop pulling in order for the pinch to go away.

The only thing I don’t like about this product is the fact that it’s mostly made of plastic. Although this plastic is a high-grade polymer, and even though it is held together with steel pins, this is a slight issue. However, this is a tool that will usually be used under close supervision, so there is little chance that your dog will chew this thing.

The best feature of this collar is the fact that you can change the links or add more of them. The product comes with some extra links, and more can be purchased. In this way, you can modify the collar for a dog of any size.


  • Effective in controlling the dog
  • Soft spikes cause no discomfort until the dog pulls
  • All connecting pieces are made of steel
  • Looks like a normal collar when worn
  • Great for owners of large dogs


  • Dog fur will sometimes get caught between the links
  • Too much plastic
  • No warranty
MoonPi Dog Muzzle with Nylon Collar Adjustable Basket Muzzle Breathable Leather Dog Mouth Cover Anti-Biting,Barking,Chewing,Surgery Recovery for Large Dog Black
19 Reviews
MoonPi Dog Muzzle with Nylon Collar Adjustable Basket Muzzle Breathable Leather Dog Mouth Cover Anti-Biting,Barking,Chewing,Surgery Recovery for Large Dog Black
  • Large soft leather dog muzzle and nylon...
  • Basket Muzzle can effectively prevent dogs...
  • Large adjustable dog mouth cover with 2...
  • This mesh mask adopt soft and smooth leather,...

This is a very good collar for dogs with aggression issues. Biting is among the most serious problems that a dog owner can face, because of the potential legal ramifications if your dog causes harm to a person or another animal. This is why a muzzle is needed. A muzzle removes any opportunity to bite, forcing the dog to behave.

This collar is made of good, sturdy leather and is held together with steel buckles and grommets. I really like the fact that this muzzle has three buckles instead of one. Some of the muzzles on the market are simply not strong enough to hold a determined dog.

The most distinctive feature of this product is the way that it attaches to a collar. The muzzle comes with a very wide nylon collar, and there is a loop on the back. The main strap of the muzzle goes through this loop, ensuring that both collar and muzzle are a tight fit.


  • Combination of collar and muzzle provides maximum security
  • Three buckles
  • Well-ventilated so as not to obstruct breathing
  • Made for comfort
  • Effectively stops biting and chewing


  • Nylon collar has plastic clasps, though they are very thick
  • Leather can stretch over time
  • Main strap could be a little thicker
COVONO Underground Dog Containment System,Electric Dog Fence (In Ground Pet Fence,650Ft Wire,Waterproof,Rechargeable Collar,Static/Tone Correction,Support 2 Dogs)
27 Reviews
COVONO Underground Dog Containment System,Electric Dog Fence (In Ground Pet Fence,650Ft Wire,Waterproof,Rechargeable Collar,Static/Tone Correction,Support 2 Dogs)
  • NEW VERSION FOR 2019: Features a pure black...
  • 100% SECURITY GUARANTEE: We are very...
  • LARGE SYSTEM CAPACITY: The included 650 feet...
  • DURABLE COLLAR RECEIVER: The receiver is...

This is the only shock collar on our list, as we already talked about dog shock collars in a previous article. This one differs from those that we reviewed previously because of the fact that it is paired with an underground fence.

The idea is to create an invisible barrier that your dog cannot cross without receiving a shock. Covono offers one of the best invisible fences on the market. This kit comes with everything you need to get started. The bands of the collars are very wide and look to be made of high-quality leather. The receivers are thick and bulky but seem very durable. In fact, all of the parts seem to be very large.

You get 650 feet of wire with this kit, which means you can cover up to three-quarters of an acre. Unless you have a very large yard, you should only need one kit. The manufacturer offers a “100% security guarantee.” If this is what it sounds like, it is an excellent benefit. This would basically mean that if your dog escapes, you get your money back. The product also comes with a lifetime warranty, which is always good.

This product is designed with the multiple-dog owner in mind. This particular system can support as many dogs as you have, though each dog will need a receiver. You can manage all of them from the same console.


  • Allows precise control of boundaries
  • Can support an unlimited number of receivers
  • Lifetime warranty and security guarantee
  • 650 feet of wire
  • Complete kit with everything you need


  • May not deter the largest or most stubborn dogs
  • Subject to failure due to power blackout
  • Receiver is kind of large
Country Brook Design - Martingale Heavyduty Nylon Dog Collar (Large, 1 Inch Wide, Black)
836 Reviews
Country Brook Design - Martingale Heavyduty Nylon Dog Collar (Large, 1 Inch Wide, Black)
  • 1 INCH WIDTH | Adjustable from 18 inch - 26...
  • Personalize your pup with rich, fashionable...
  • Take your friend for a jog while he wears...
  • Durable and heavy duty materials that give...

The Martingale collar is a design that isn’t particularly well-known. Unlike most of the collars on this list, it is meant for dogs whose problems are not quite as extreme. This type of collar could be described as a limited choke collar. It has an extra loop that can be pulled to tighten the leash, but it cannot tighten very far.

Not only can this be an option for less stubborn dogs, but it can also be a graduation option for dogs who have made progress. In other words, you can start a difficult dog with a pinch collar, and when their behavior improves, this collar can be their next level of training.


  • Well-suited for the less-extreme cases
  • Thick, double-layered construction
  • All connections are made of thick steel
  • Good for a graduated option
  • Offers discipline similar to a choke collar, but without the choking


  • Not suitable for extreme cases
  • Some buyers haver reported sharp ends on the nylon straps
Garmin T5 GPS Dog Collar
35 Reviews
Garmin T5 GPS Dog Collar
  • High-Sensitivity GPS with GLONASS;Range: 9...
  • LED beacon lights and Rescue mode. Neck...
  • Battery life 20-40 hrs. Water rating: 1 ATM...
  • T 5 tracking dog device w/ rechargeable...

Although this is more than a little bit on the expensive side, this is the best solution for a dog that continually runs away. Garmin makes a lot of GPS devices, most of which are intended to be used in your car. As such, it is a pretty trusted name.

This thing comes with a handset that looks more like a cellphone. It allows you to track your dog’s location on a map with extreme precision. It would be very hard to lose your dog with a device like this. The handset can track up to 20 dogs at once, although very few would ever need to do so.

This product is only rated for use within the United States and Canada, so it probably won’t be a good option if you live anywhere else. Within those borders, however, it can track the approximate distance that the dog has traveled from home, how fast they are traveling, and how long it has been since they left home.

The whole thing works by bouncing signals off satellites and updates every 2.5 seconds. Although not everyone can afford it, you really couldn’t ask for a better tracking collar. Obviously, this is an extreme solution, but for some dog owners, it may be the only solution.


  • Extremely precise location
  • Tracks speed, distance, and duration
  • Tracks up to 20 dogs at once
  • Works by satellite so terrain doesn’t matter much
  • Updates every 2.5 seconds


  • Receiver is pretty large
  • Expensive
  • Only works in the U.S. and Canada


In this case, it is not possible to choose just one product and proclaim it to be “the best.” This is because your needs will be the main determining factor in your decision. For this article, we have tried to simply present you with all the best options so that you can make an informed choice based on your problem and your situation.

For instance, if you are having issues with your dog running off and getting lost, the GPS collar is what you will need. For this situation, a muzzle or a pinch collar would do nothing to remedy your problem.

Garmin T5 GPS Dog Collar
35 Reviews
Garmin T5 GPS Dog Collar
  • High-Sensitivity GPS with GLONASS;Range: 9...
  • LED beacon lights and Rescue mode. Neck...
  • Battery life 20-40 hrs. Water rating: 1 ATM...
  • T 5 tracking dog device w/ rechargeable...

However, pet owners who are dealing with an aggressive dog will find little use in the GPS collar or the underground fence.

We hope you have enjoyed this article, and that you have obtained all the information you need to solve your problems and help your wayward little friend to learn what is expected of them.

Last update on 2019-10-03